"You dumb fuck! You dumb fuck!"
That's what I kept screaming at myself. Probably a thousand times. After reading one chapter of a book.
Richard Thaler describes a phenomenon where the person who wins a bid is often the one who overestimated the upside and underestimated the cost. That's it. That's the whole idea. And shit, it hit me right in the face.
Because when information is incomplete — and it's never complete, not on any job you've ever quoted — the optimistic one always gets punished.
Yeah. I'm that optimistic idiot.
The lines I said out loud
"I think we overestimated the work days here."
"Supplier said he can support us with a lower price."
"Material costs dropped recently... should we use the latest numbers?"
Those are real lines. I've said all three, in that tone of voice, leaning over a spreadsheet, going line by line, trimming costs, massaging numbers, convincing myself and everyone in the room that we could fucking make it work.
And then the one that ends you:
"Let's get the job first. We'll worry about that later."
The moment that sentence leaves your mouth, you're not estimating anymore. You've stopped pricing work and started negotiating with yourself. Desperation isn't a cost line, so it never shows up in the spreadsheet. It just quietly deletes margin before the job even starts.
Why the curse lands on the contractor
Thaler's point is about auctions. My trade isn't an auction. It's worse.
In an auction, everyone sees roughly the same object and bids against each other. In a cold room bid, every contractor is estimating a different number of work days, a different material price, a different labour assumption, a different guess about how bad the site will be. The bid isn't a measurement of cost. It's a measurement of optimism.
And the winner is not the best contractor. The winner is the most optimistic one. The job goes to whoever believed hardest that it could be done for less.
So when you win, ask yourself what you actually won. A contract, or the right to prove you were wrong?
Where it shows up in a cold room
It shows up in the places nobody prices honestly.
The racking handling. It gets counted as "installation" and then the actual hours disappear on site, because the room wasn't drawn around the workflow and every bay fought the forklift.
The ante room. First to get cut when the number's too high. And then the client stages product in ambient air in front of the door, and it's your name on the drawing.
The heat load. Guessed, because it's fast and the client wants a number by Friday. You've sized equipment against a guess about a room that doesn't exist yet.
The second shift. The five-year growth. The thing the client says they'll "see how it goes" on. Every one of those is a cost sitting off the page, and you're the one who eats it.
None of these are engineering mistakes. Every one of them is an optimism mistake. They're all the same whisper: it'll probably be fine.
The uncomfortable part
I was not being smart.
I was not being rational.
I was not being strategic.
I was just an optimistic Excel monkey, and the spreadsheet was my echo chamber. Every row I trimmed agreed with me. That's what a spreadsheet does when you're the only one allowed to touch it.
What I do differently now
You cannot delete optimism. I've tried. It's the reason anyone starts a business.
So I price it instead.
I budget a number for the unknown, and I write it down before I get excited. I keep the worst job I've ever done in the back of my head, and I ask whether this quote looks like it. And I stopped treating "let's get the job first" as strategy. It's a symptom. When I catch myself saying it, I know the number is fiction.
The curse never goes away. You just stop letting it sign your name.
The part that stings
Everything in that chapter lives in a place we don't look. Not in a compressor, not in a panel, not in a heat load. It lives in the meeting, in the spreadsheet, in the sentence you say to yourself when the number's a little too high and you want the job a little too much.
Which is the same thing I keep saying in this newsletter, from a different angle. The business isn't in the box. It never was.
If you've ever said "let's get the job first" and regretted it, I want to hear what it cost you. Reply to this and tell me the number. I'll keep it anonymous.
Next issue, back to racking. Another past project, this one with push-back and selective in the same room, and the decision I hadn't had to make before: when do you give a client both systems instead of picking one?